Search tools
Did you mean: can a person become a black sheep and a scapegoat
AI Overview
+3
Yes, a person can be both the black sheep and the scapegoat, as these roles often overlap, especially in dysfunctional families. The black sheep is typically seen as different, an outcast for their nonconformity, while the scapegoat is actively blamed for the family’s problems to deflect from other issues.
Overlap between the roles
- Dysfunctional family roles: In a dysfunctional or abusive family, the roles of black sheep and scapegoat often overlap because the family system uses them to maintain its toxic dynamics.
- Blame and blame deflection: The person who stands out (black sheep) becomes an easy target for blame (scapegoat) because their individuality can be used to deflect from the family’s deeper issues.
- Unfair treatment: Both roles involve unfair treatment where negative feelings like anger, frustration, and blame are projected onto one person.
- Differentiation: While often confused, they are distinct. A black sheep might simply be seen as different, while a scapegoat is actively and unfairly blamed. However, in many cases, the black sheep becomes the scapegoat.
- Example: A person with different values or interests from the rest of the family might be labeled the “black sheep” and then also become the “scapegoat” when their family needs someone to blame for a conflict.
How the roles function
- Scapegoat: This is a person who is blamed for the problems of others. They are often singled out for unmerited negative treatment to protect the rest of the group from facing their own issues.
- Black Sheep: This is a term for someone who doesn’t fit in with the family, often due to different values or behaviors. While it implies nonconformity, it is less about wrongdoing and more about being an outsider.
Dive deeper in AI Mode
AI responses may include mistakes. Learn more
Quora1 answer · 2 years agoCan someone be both the black sheep and scapegoat in one family …
Can someone be both the black sheep and scapegoat in one family (or person)? How would that work exactly?
Yes absolutely possible and I’m sure experienced by many. Two examples. The first is you’re married to an amazing spouse but you haven’t learned …More
Top answer · 5 votes
Can a person be the ‘family’s black sheep’ and/or ‘scapegoat’ if they don …4 answers·1y
What is the difference between a black sheep, outcast and scapegoat?3 answers·2y
People also ask
Is the black sheep the scapegoat?
What type of person becomes a scapegoat?
What causes someone to be a black sheep?
Which child is usually the scapegoat?
Feedback
Sorry for the essay. To sum it up I believe people can be both the scapegoat and black sheep in the family. Pandoratastic. • 10mo ago.
Any empaths that are also the scapegoat/black sheep of their …r/Empaths·40+ comments·1y
Psychology Todayhttps://www.psychologytoday.comThe Power of Being “The Black Sheep” of the Family
Jan 17, 2022 — Black-sheep or scapegoat archetypes are prevalent in cultures worldwide. The black sheep may be the scapegoat for a family’s dysfunctional …
Laura K. Connellhttps://www.laurakconnell.comAre you the family scapegoat? Here are 9 signs
Nov 9, 2024 — But when you say or do the same things you get maligned. In psychology, this is known as the black sheep effect. 5. You feel left out as the …
Videos
10:18
Signs you might be the family scapegoatYouTube · Psychology with Dr. AnaMar 5, 2025
5 signs you’re the black sheep or scapegoat of a family: 1) You don’t fit in, 2) Your life choices are seen as a threat, 3) You’re punished for pointing out dysfunction, 4) Negative traits are projected onto you, 5) You’re blamed for every conflict.
13:18
Being the Family Scapegoat or Problem Child: Honesty About …YouTube · Tim FletcherAug 15, 2024
Scapegoats in dysfunctional families are honest about the family’s pain and rebellion against it but are ostracized and develop problems like emotional shutdown and manipulation.
5:39
Scapegoats in families are often ostracized, blamed, and gossiped about by their siblings and parents.
Feedback
Jennifer Nurickhttps://jennynurick.comBlack Sheep: The Scapegoat
Jul 31, 2022 — The person who suffers from this dynamic is the scapegoat. If you know you were scapegoated as a child, know that MANY scapegoats go on to have …
Page includes:
, Symptoms
Dec 19, 2024 — Being the black sheep or scapegoat often means being the one who breaks cycles, questions norms, or brings hidden truths to light. This can be …
Being the family scapegoat, a ‘black sheep’ such as an alienated child or parent, is an emotionally distressing experience.
Black sheep of the family is someone who is marginalised, scapegoated, misunderstood. They may be particularly sensitive, emotionally intense, curious, …
People also search for
The Play Therapisthttps://theplaytherapist.com4 Types of Dysfunctional Family Roles
The Scapegoat is also referred to as the “black sheep” of the family, and has a hard time fitting in and relating to the other family members. His/her behavior …
Results are personalized-Try without personalization
Riverside, Ohio – From your device
Update location
Dark theme: offHelpFeedbackPrivacyTerms
AI overview is ready
Site Title 